Best Premier League Goalkeepers for Teams Outside the Big 6

As a part of our series on Premier League goalkeepers, and after taking a look at the biggest names and their stats, today EPLNews brings you the best goalies who played the most significant part of their careers for clubs outside the division’s Big Six.

These shot-stoppers have showcased remarkable skill, consistency, and resilience, often under the radar. Read on to find out who makes our list and why.

Mark Schwarzer (Middlesbrough, Fulham)

Mark Schwarzer’s Premier League journey is a testament to longevity and consistency. The Australian goalkeeper amassed an impressive 514 Premier League appearances, keeping 152 clean sheets. His stints at Middlesbrough and Fulham were particularly noteworthy, with Schwarzer playing pivotal roles in both clubs’ successes during his tenure.

Notably, he was instrumental in Fulham’s remarkable run to the UEFA Europa League final in 2010. Schwarzer’s reliability and shot-stopping abilities made him a standout performer outside the Big Six.

Shay Given (Newcastle United, Aston Villa)

Irish international Shay Given was a mainstay in the Premier League, most prominently with Newcastle United, where he made over 350 appearances. Known for his agility and reflexes, Given was often the last line of defense for Newcastle during both stable and tumultuous periods. He later brought his experience to Aston Villa, continuing to perform at a high level. Given’s consistency and leadership were invaluable assets to his teams.

Brad Friedel (Blackburn Rovers, Aston Villa)

American goalkeeper Brad Friedel was renowned for his durability and consistency. During his time with Blackburn Rovers and later Aston Villa, Friedel set a record for the most consecutive Premier League appearances, highlighting his fitness and reliability. His shot-stopping prowess and commanding presence in the box made him a formidable opponent for strikers across the league.

Jussi Jääskeläinen (Bolton Wanderers, West Ham United)

Finnish goalkeeper Jussi Jääskeläinen was a key figure for Bolton Wanderers, making over 500 appearances for the club in all competitions. His tenure included helping Bolton achieve their highest-ever Premier League finish and qualify for European competition. Jääskeläinen’s reflexes and penalty-saving abilities were standout aspects of his game, earning him respect across the league.

Jordan Pickford (Everton)

Jordan Pickford has been a crucial player for Everton since his arrival, known for his distribution and shot-stopping skills. As of this season, Pickford has maintained a high level of performance, contributing significantly to Everton’s defensive efforts. His leadership and experience have also been vital for the England national team, where he has consistently been the first-choice goalkeeper in major tournaments.

Nick Pope (Burnley, Newcastle United)

Nick Pope’s rise to prominence began with Burnley, where his performances earned him a reputation as one of the league’s top goalkeepers. After moving to Newcastle United, Pope continued to excel, contributing to the team’s defensive solidity. His shot-stopping ability and command of the penalty area have been key factors in Newcastle’s recent successes.

Emiliano Martínez (Aston Villa)

After a long stint as a backup at Arsenal, Emiliano Martínez’s move to Aston Villa marked the beginning of his emergence as a top-tier goalkeeper. His performances have been characterized by crucial saves, leadership, and a commanding presence in the box. Martínez’s contributions have been instrumental in Aston Villa’s strong defensive records in recent seasons.

He is also a World Cup winner with Argentina, having made some incredible saves and contributing to his national team’s success at the 2022 FIFA World Cup.

Bernd Leno (Fulham)

Bernd Leno, formerly of Arsenal, found a new lease on life at Fulham, where he has been a standout performer. His shot-stopping abilities and composure under pressure have been critical in Fulham’s efforts to establish themselves in the Premier League. Leno’s experience and skill set have provided stability to Fulham’s defense.

Matz Sels (Nottingham Forest)

Belgian goalkeeper Matz Sels has been a revelation in an over-performing Nottingham Forest side this season. His performances have been marked by crucial saves and consistent displays, contributing significantly to Forest’s defensive record. Sels’ agility and shot-stopping prowess have made him one of the standout goalkeepers in the league.

Mark Flekken (Brentford)

Dutch goalkeeper Mark Flekken has been a key figure for Brentford, known for his reflexes and distribution. His performances have helped Brentford maintain their Premier League status, with Flekken often making crucial saves to secure points for his team. His consistency and reliability have been assets for Brentford’s defensive setup. He is the goalkeeper with the highest number of saves in this season of the EPL.

Conclusion

These goalkeepers have demonstrated that excellence between the posts isn’t confined to the Premier League’s traditional powerhouses. Their contributions have been vital to their respective clubs, showcasing that talent and determination can shine brightly, regardless of club stature.