Best Relegated Players In Premier League History
We continue our series of articles about Premier League relegations with an article about players who stood out thanks to their individual performances despite being part of sides that went down a division.
You can also read about the worst EPL teams in history, as well as our article about bad luck and shocking relegations.
Throughout Premier League history, several players have delivered outstanding individual performances for teams that ultimately faced relegation. These exceptional displays often caught the attention of bigger clubs, leading to transfers that allowed these talents to continue their careers in the top flight. Here are the most important examples.
Roy Keane (Nottingham Forest, 1992/93)
In the inaugural Premier League season, Roy Keane emerged as a standout performer for Nottingham Forest. Despite the team’s struggles, Keane’s commanding presence in midfield and leadership qualities were evident.
His performances did not go unnoticed, and following Forest’s relegation, Manchester United secured his services for a British record transfer fee at the time. Keane went on to become a pivotal figure at Old Trafford, captaining the side to numerous titles, including the historic treble in 1999.
Joe Cole (West Ham United, 2002/03)
A product of West Ham’s esteemed youth academy, Joe Cole was handed the captain’s armband at just 21 during the 2002/03 season. His creativity and flair in midfield were among the few bright spots in a challenging campaign for the Hammers.
Following their relegation, Cole transferred to Chelsea for £6.6 million. He flourished at Stamford Bridge, contributing to three Premier League titles and two FA Cup victories over seven seasons, amassing 281 appearances for the Blues.
Andy Robertson (Hull City, 2016/17)
Despite Hull City’s relegation in the 2016/17 season, left-back Andy Robertson showcased remarkable consistency and resilience. His performances earned him a move to Liverpool in 2017 for £8 million, in what is still believed to be one of the best pieces of business involving the Reds in the last three decades.
At Anfield, Robertson developed into one of the world’s premier left-backs, playing a crucial role in Liverpool’s Premier League and UEFA Champions League triumphs.
James Milner (Leeds United, 2003/04)
Milner began his career at Leeds United, making his debut at the age of 16. Following Leeds’ relegation in the 2003/04 season, Milner moved to Newcastle United, marking the start of a distinguished Premier League journey.
His versatility and professionalism led him to Manchester City, where he secured two Premier League titles. Later, at Liverpool, Milner added another league title and a Champions League medal to his collection, solidifying his status as one of the league’s most reliable performers.
Georginio Wijnaldum (Newcastle United, 2015/16)
Dutch midfielder Georginio Wijnaldum joined Newcastle United in 2015 and made an immediate impact, finishing as the club’s top scorer with 11 goals. Despite his efforts, Newcastle faced relegation that season.
Recognising his talent, Liverpool signed Wijnaldum in the summer of 2016. At Liverpool, he became an integral part of the midfield, contributing to the club’s Champions League victory in 2019 and Premier League title in 2020.
Jermaine Defoe (West Ham United, 2002/03)
Another one from the ill-fated 2002/03 season for the Hammers, Jermaine Defoe’s goal-scoring prowess was evident during West Ham’s campaign, where he netted 11 league goals.
Following the team’s relegation, Defoe transferred to Tottenham Hotspur in 2004. Over two spells at Spurs, he became one of the Premier League’s most consistent strikers, amassing over 90 goals for the club and earning a place among the league’s top scorers.
Michael Carrick (West Ham United, 2002/03)
Midfielder Michael Carrick was yet another standout in West Ham’s heartbreaking 2002/03 season. After spending an additional season in the Championship, he moved to Tottenham Hotspur in 2004, joining fellow former Boleyn Ground favourite Defoe.
His impressive displays at Spurs led to a transfer to Manchester United in 2006, where Carrick enjoyed a decorated career, winning multiple Premier League titles and the Champions League in 2008.
Conclusion
These players exemplify how individual excellence can shine through even in challenging team circumstances. Their subsequent moves to prominent clubs not only revitalised their careers, but also underscored the importance of scouting talent beyond immediate team success.