Who Could Manchester City Target to Replace Rodri in January?

Following a wretched run that saw them win just one game from their last 11 across all competitions, speculation surrounding Manchester City signing a replacement for their injured midfielder Rodri has intensified.

The Ballon d’Or winner faces a lengthy spell on the sidelines after suffering an anterior cruciate ligament injury against Arsenal in September. With Rodri likely out for the remainder of the season, City find themselves needing reinforcements.

While Mateo Kovacic has stepped into the role, his performances have been inconsistent, leaving Pep Guardiola’s side susceptible to counter-attacks. Below, we examine the midfielders linked with City as potential January signings to fit the bill as the best Rodri replacement—and to complement him when he returns.

Martin Zubimendi (Real Sociedad)

The 25-year-old Spain international has frequently been linked with Manchester City since Rodri’s injury. Liverpool reportedly showed interest during the summer transfer window, but Zubimendi chose to remain at Real Sociedad.

With a reported £51.7m release clause, the fee is unlikely to deter City from pursuing the defensive midfielder, who is equally comfortable in a more advanced role. Zubimendi has previously partnered with Rodri for Spain and impressed when stepping in for him during the second half of Spain’s EURO 2024 final victory over England.

Although Sociedad regularly feature in European competitions, this is only Zubimendi’s first season playing Champions League football, which may raise concerns about his experience at the highest level.

Ederson (Atalanta)

Another name linked with City is 25-year-old Brazilian midfielder Ederson. A vital part of Atalanta’s setup, Ederson is versatile, capable of playing both centrally and in deeper or more advanced roles.

While this season marks his debut in the Champions League, which may give City pause, his age makes him a potential long-term investment. Any move for Ederson would likely command a substantial fee, reflecting his importance to Atalanta and his potential to grow further.

Samuele Ricci (Torino)

At just 23 years old, Italian international Samuele Ricci was among the first players rumoured to be on City’s radar after Rodri’s injury. Reports suggest City scouts attended Torino’s match against Inter Milan to evaluate Ricci’s performance.

Able to play as a defensive midfielder or slightly further forward, Ricci has become a regular in Italy’s national team since EURO 2024. However, his lack of European club competition experience might work against him. Ricci has openly admitted to studying videos of Rodri to refine his game, raising intrigue about how he might adapt alongside the Spaniard.

Hakan Çalhanoğlu (Inter Milan)

The 30-year-old Turkish midfielder has also emerged as a potential target. Boasting extensive Champions League experience, Çalhanoğlu is noted for his versatility. Primarily a defensive midfielder, he can also push forward when needed.

Reports suggest Inter Milan may be open to selling him, and with Bayern Munich—managed by ex-City captain Vincent Kompany—also reportedly interested, Guardiola’s team might face competition for his signature. Çalhanoğlu’s experience could make him an attractive short-term solution.

Tijjani Reijnders (AC Milan)

At 26, Dutch midfielder Tijjani Reijnders is another name mentioned in connection with City. Reports indicate that the club has “tested the waters” for a potential move, while Milan are reportedly preparing to increase his wages to deter suitors.

Reijnders operates primarily as a central midfielder and could complement Rodri upon his return. With two seasons of Champions League experience under his belt, Reijnders brings a level of familiarity with top-tier football that may appeal to Guardiola.

Adam Wharton (Crystal Palace)

The youngest name on the list, 20-year-old Adam Wharton, has drawn attention from several Premier League clubs following his strong performances for Crystal Palace. Having joined the Eagles in January, Wharton’s impressive form earned him a call-up to England’s EURO 2024 squad.

However, the left-footed midfielder has struggled for form this season and is currently sidelined after undergoing groin surgery. While a January move appears unlikely, City and other top-tier clubs will undoubtedly continue monitoring his development.

Frenkie de Jong (Barcelona)

Frequently linked with the Premier League in the past, 27-year-old Dutch midfielder Frenkie de Jong has opted to remain with Barcelona. While his name hasn’t been recently connected to City, his ability to play a more advanced role could make him an intriguing option.

De Jong’s wealth of experience in both domestic and European competitions adds to his appeal, but his current struggles with form and fitness might deter City from pursuing him as an immediate solution.

Leon Goretzka (Bayern Munich)

At 29, Germany international Leon Goretzka could provide an experienced option for City. However, he is not a natural replacement for Rodri and has fallen out of favour at Bayern Munich.

While Goretzka’s vast Champions League experience and physicality might add a new dimension to City’s midfield, a move for him feels improbable at this stage.

Nicolò Barella (Inter Milan)

Arguably the most high-profile name on this list, 27-year-old Nicolò Barella would be a dream signing for City. Guardiola has reportedly long admired the Italian, but Inter’s reliance on Barella makes a January transfer highly unlikely.

Barella’s versatility and ability to complement Rodri make him an ideal candidate, but any move for him would likely have to wait until the summer.

Comparing the Candidates’ 2024/25 Seasons

Finding a replacement for Rodri is no easy task, particularly given his status as the world’s best defensive midfielder. However, analysing the linked players reveals some interesting insights.

Zubimendi stands out for his defensive contributions, with an average of 2.6 tackles, 1.1 interceptions, and 2.2 clearances per 90 minutes—the highest among the candidates. While his passing accuracy (86.9%) is solid, his volume of attempted passes is among the lowest. Playing for a side like City, which dominates possession, could unlock further potential in Zubimendi’s game.

Players like Reijnders and Çalhanoğlu could offer ball-playing qualities, particularly if Rodri returns to a deeper role. Çalhanoğlu’s ability to deliver passes into the final third is especially noteworthy.

Meanwhile, Ricci’s potential remains untapped. Torino’s position in mid-table Serie A might mask his capabilities, which could flourish in City’s possession-heavy system. Similarly, Wharton’s left-footed balance could bring a unique dimension to City’s midfield when fit.

What Makes Rodri Irreplaceable?

Rodri’s contributions to Manchester City are unmatched, highlighted by his Champions League-winning goal and Ballon d’Or triumph. Initially questioned as Fernandinho’s successor, Rodri has since developed into a world-class player.

Last season, he was instrumental in City’s Treble-winning campaign, with nine goals, increased passing accuracy, and improved defensive contributions. Comparing his statistics to the aforementioned candidates illustrates the challenge any new signing faces. Rodri leads in attempted and completed passes, duels won, and ranks highly in tackles and interceptions.

While no single player can fully replicate Rodri’s influence, City’s recruitment strategy will focus on finding a midfielder capable of bolstering their squad now and complementing Rodri’s game upon his return.