Top 6 ‘Sixes’ to Ever Play in the EPL

The Premier League has seen a host of world-class talent over the years, especially in the defensive midfield role. This position is crucial, acting as a shield in front of the defence, breaking up opposition play, and transitioning defence into attack.

Let’s dive into the six best defensive midfielders in Premier League history (in no particular order), examining their stats, trophies, and what made them stand out.

Claude Makélélé

   – Clubs: Chelsea (2003–2008)  

   – Premier League Appearances: 144  

   – Goals: 2

   – Wins/Losses: 102/14

   – Trophies: 2 Premier League titles, 1 FA Cup, 2 League Cups

Claude Makélélé redefined the defensive midfield role during his time at Chelsea. After arriving from Real Madrid in 2003, he became the backbone of a formidable Chelsea side under José Mourinho. Known for his ability to intercept, tackle, and maintain positional discipline, Makélélé’s influence led to the term “the Makélélé role” to describe the lone defensive midfield position.

He wasn’t a prolific goal-scorer but contributed in ways that went beyond stats, controlling the game’s tempo and breaking up play to protect his defence. His role was instrumental in Chelsea’s back-to-back Premier League titles in 2004-05 and 2005-06, where Chelsea conceded just 15 goals during the 2004-05 season—a record that still stands.

Patrick Vieira

   – Clubs: Arsenal (1996–2005), Manchester City (2009-2011)

   – Premier League Appearances: 307  

   – Goals: 31

   – Wins/Losses: 186/43

   – Trophies: 3 Premier League titles, 4 FA Cups

Patrick Vieira was a towering presence in Arsenal’s midfield during his time at the club. A leader on and off the pitch, Vieira captained Arsenal’s “Invincibles” side in the 2003-04 season, going undefeated throughout the campaign. Known for his physicality, tackling, and passing range, Vieira could transition from defence to attack seamlessly.

His ability to dictate play while maintaining a tough defensive presence was pivotal to Arsenal’s success. Vieira was named in the PFA Team of the Year six times, a testament to his dominance in the league. His battle with Roy Keane, both on and off the field, was one of the Premier League’s most storied rivalries.

Roy Keane

   – Clubs: Manchester United (1993–2006), Nottingham Forest (1992-1993)

   – Premier League Appearances: 366

   – Goals: 39

   – Wins/Losses: 220/61

   – Trophies: 7 Premier League titles, 4 FA Cups, 1 Champions League

Roy Keane was the heart and soul of Manchester United’s midfield for over a decade. Known for his aggressive style and fierce determination, Keane was a natural leader, serving as captain during United’s most successful era. His role was not limited to just breaking up play; he was also known for his passing range and ability to control the game.

Keane’s leadership skills were crucial in United’s treble-winning season in 1998-99. He played with a relentless desire to win, making him one of the most feared midfielders in Premier League history. His rivalry with Patrick Vieira epitomised the intense competition between Manchester United and Arsenal during the late ’90s and early 2000s.

N’Golo Kanté

   – Clubs: Leicester City (2015–2016), Chelsea (2016–2024)  

   – Premier League Appearances: 227  

   – Goals: 12

   – Wins/Losses: 130/46

   – Trophies: 2 Premier League titles, 1 FA Cup, 1 Champions League, 1 Europa League

N’Golo Kanté’s rise from an unknown entity at Leicester City to one of the best midfielders in the world is nothing short of remarkable. His tireless work ethic, ability to cover ground, and knack for intercepting the ball make him one of the most efficient defensive midfielders of his generation.

Kanté was instrumental in Leicester City’s fairytale Premier League triumph in 2015-16 and repeated the feat with Chelsea the following season, becoming the first player to win consecutive Premier League titles with two different clubs. He has been named Premier League Player of the Season (2016-17) and was included in the PFA Team of the Year twice, highlighting his significant impact in the league.

Fernandinho

   – Clubs: Manchester City (2013–2023)  

   – Premier League Appearances: 264  

   – Goals: 20

   – Wins/Losses: 187/40

   – Trophies: 5 Premier League titles, 1 FA Cup, 6 League Cups

Fernandinho was the linchpin of Manchester City’s midfield for nearly a decade. A versatile player capable of playing as a defensive midfielder or centre-back, Fernandinho was known for his tactical intelligence, ball-winning ability, and leadership on the field. He played a crucial role in Manchester City’s success under Pep Guardiola, contributing to the club’s dominance with five league titles.

His ability to read the game allowed City to maintain their high defensive line and aggressive pressing style. Fernandinho’s influence went beyond defensive duties, as he was capable of contributing to City’s attack with his accurate passing and long-range shots.

Michael Essien

   – Clubs: Chelsea (2005–2014)  

   – Premier League Appearances: 168

   – Goals: 17

   – Wins/Losses: 113/22

   – Trophies: 2 Premier League titles, 4 FA Cups, 1 League Cup, 1 Champions League

Michael Essien, affectionately known as “The Bison,” brought energy, strength, and versatility to Chelsea’s midfield. His physical prowess and tackling ability made him a fan favourite at Stamford Bridge. Essien was not only a defensive enforcer but also possessed an incredible engine, allowing him to make powerful runs forward.

His memorable long-range goals and ability to break up play made him one of the most well-rounded defensive midfielders of his time. Essien played a significant role in Chelsea’s league titles and was part of the squad that lifted the Champions League in 2012, although he missed the final due to injury.

Honourable Mentions

The Premier League has seen many other incredible defensive midfielders who have narrowly missed this list but still left their mark. Players like Gilberto Silva (Arsenal), Javier Mascherano (West Ham, Liverpool), and Gareth Barry (Aston Villa, Manchester City, Everton) were all pivotal to their teams’ successes.

Probably unlucky to not find a place in our top six ‘sixes’ is Manchester City’s Rodri. However we are certain that if we revisit this article in a couple of years he will feature in it, perhaps even as the best ever.

Final Thoughts

Each of these six players brought something unique to the defensive midfield role in the Premier League. From Keane’s leadership to Kanté’s tireless work rate, they all contributed to their teams’ success and left an indelible mark on the league.

As defensive midfielders, their primary focus was not to score or assist but to provide stability, cover the defence, and control the pace of the game. Their contributions may not always show up on the scoresheet, but their influence has been felt in the trophy cabinets and hearts of the fans.

In an era where defensive midfielders are more versatile and integral to the modern game, these six players set the standard, paving the way for future generations. We here at EPLNews, along with all other Premier League fans, have been fortunate to witness such exceptional talent, and these legends will continue to inspire players for years to come.